1. What is the scholastic method? From what i read my understanding is that the scholastic way is a way to understand and critizise the literature of an author. for example they talk about how the students would read the literature carefully and would learn to appreciate the thoughts of the author. It also states that there was 2 steps of analizing the literature, one of the steps was Philological analysis which means that you would try to find hidden meanings in certain words, you would try to look for words that the author could have used that have other meaning rather than the logical realistic meanings. Then comes the second step which is called the Logical analysis, during the logical analysis you read the literature and analyze it using regular logic, or in other words putting together the thoughts of the author exactly the way its written with no hidden meanings or uses in the litterature. It also States that Anselm was one of the Philosophers that contributed to he Scholastic Method, this was started in an effort to defend and support his religious beliefs.
2. What are “sententiae” and how did they figure in the scholasticmethod? The sententiae were used as the points of disagreement and contention, they were a few sentences that were wirtten to describe the different sources. From the reading it states that the disagreement and contentions in the Sententiae would be written out in a way where the two sides would be in agreement, this process of evaluation took 2 days to be completed.
3. What was the aim of the scholastic method? What were they trying todo? to my understanding it seems that this method enabled people to analyze and view things in 2 ways, rather than just one. in other words it made you think in and outside the box. For example you would analize the literature in a logical way word by word, then you would analyze it again and try to find hidden meanings in words or in sentences. I dont like the idea that alot of this method was derrived from religion, it seems like it was used to cover up a lot of the flaws of the religious literature, i dont understand why you would have to undertand an author logically and Philologically. To me it seems like the philosophers would use those 2 methods so that they could pick the best qualities that are in the favor either by choosing some of the views and ideas logically or Philologically.
4. What was “philology” and how did the scholastics use it? Like i have stated before in my opinion Philology was used to find hidden meanings in literature, or analyze words that the author may have used to portray a different ideas.
5. For the scholastics, what was the purpose of logical analysis? The purpose was to analyze an authors literature logically word by word, in other words their ideas would be represented by exactly what it would mean to a regular person if they read it, with no hidden views or ideas.
7.hat did Bonaventure think was our relationship to God? Bonaventure thought that every thing revolved aroung God, and that God was at the center of everything because he had created everything. He believed that everything could be derived by religious faith, He though that views an ideas could be reached by having faith. in other words nothing could be argued or analyzed before using religious faith as an instrument.
8. What did Aquinas think is the right relationship between faith andreason? Aquinas believed that is was possible to support religius beliefs and ideas. He believed that it was possble to prove that there was a God and that religion could incorporate the new teachings of the modern philosophers, In other words he believed that the new and the old religious beliefs could mesh and be considered to be true. He believed that there were steps to defend and prove that there was a god, he found ways to defend religion from modern thinkers. He developed a system for 5 ways to prove the existence of God.
9. How would Aquinas respond to a situation in which reasoncontradicted faith? He would probably try to incorporate the contradiction into his reasoning to probe that religion is true. In other words he would probably use the contradiction to his favor, some how he would make it a part of his religious reasoning to satisfy both his religious belief and the reasoning od the other party.
10. State the problem of universals in your own words. It seems that Universals caused a major problem because different groups with different beliefs emerged, making it harder for some one to agree in just one idea. These new groups that formed all had different views and ideas about things, in other words this caused more chaos because it made it harder to agree on just one thing. This made people dispute and support views and ideas in different ways.
11. Describe “realism” in your own words. Its the way that universals exist, For example one of the methods is Platonic realism which means that real entities exist independently from all other things, and then their is Nominalism realism which mean the certain entities exist depending on other things. It is two ways to analyze some thing for example one may think that one thing can only exist if another thing exists, or we may say that the thing can exist solely on itself with out having to depend on the existence of another thing.
12. Describe “nominalism” in your own words. Nominalism denies that universals are real, they belive that only individuals exist, and that Nominalism can account for all the relevant things that happen. They dont agree or believe in the ideas of realism because they believe that realism causes too many problems. It is the exact opposite of Realism.
Sunday, January 25, 2009
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)