Saturday, May 23, 2009

Final

1. When Russel Shorto analyzed Decartes contribution to modern philosophy and modern society, He states hpw astonished he was that a man could have over thrown 2000 years of history. Shorto mentions that Decarte's open the door to modern science, medicine, politics, and society. Its almost like Shorto was astonished with the fact that a man could find the truth in facts rather than relying on tradition or religion. Inmy opinion the most important phrase and a big contribution by Decartes was " I think, therefor i am", that just open doors in philosophy. I would agree with some of shorto's arguments, because like myself he was not a philosopher, but rather a regular person in society, critisizing and analyzing the work of a Philospher.
2. Cogito ergo sum, means i think therfore i exist. Decartes try to build a who method using this system, he believed that now he had the absolute certainty. Decartes once again used the mathematical system to lay out his reasoning, and he belived that once something is proven it becomes available as a foundation for other things. Like i mentioned earlier, for this system Decartes uses the bee wax to prove his theory. Decartes proves that one can't always depend on your senses, because they can prove us wrong and we could be assuming at that point.
With Cogito Ergo sum, Decartes tried to create a system, where you use different steps to prove things or items. Decartes used a mathematical system to lay out the steps that would make up the method. One of the things Decartes stated was " once something is proven, it becomes available as the foundation for other things" which was one of the things he really tried to achieve. One of Decartes theories was that you cant depend on your senses to prove that the object is real, because that would be assuming if you did, for example when he uses the Bee Wax to provide back up for his theory. I could see how this method could be used, and how Decartes believed it would work. But i believe that this system had too many flaws for people to even take it seriously. In my opinion i did not like the example he used such as the bee wax, though his theory did make sence by using the bee wax. I suppose that he was a great Philosopher because he found a way to back up his theory and make it some what function.
3. Decartes difinitions to the Cartesiam Dualism do not make sense, when you look at the mind and then look at the body they do not add up. I think Decartes may have tried to over think both areas more so than trying to think of a way to make both things work together. Its almost like Decartes should have chosen too either philosophize about the mind or the body. These Thoeries seemed like they contradicted each other, but Decartes did try to come up with a solution for this problem. Decartes Great Solution was that the mind and body do not work Together.Most people agree that the body and mind can't function with out each other, they believe that both are needed to work. I dont belive that his fix up was a very good fix up, to most people this did not make sense and Philosophers did not really like this thoery. In My opinion i dont think this theory worked, because to me you should be able to use your mind and body to analize or examine something. It did not make sense that these were independent because when you used your mind to analize something then used your body to analyze the same thing you would get totally different conclusions. I think it was a little too rough.
4. Berkeley believed that a person would not prove and object to be true or real, he believed that a person could only perceive an object to be true. He believed that all objects are only obtained through Perception. He believed that the object a person perceives is the object that the person knows and experiences. Berkeley believed the people were existent because they had the same or very similar views like him, so the existency of people could be proven that way. He also believed he could Prove Gods existence, he felt that God had been close to him at an earlier tim ein his life, because God had put thoughts in his mind so that he could perceive things. I think his thoeries are good and bad, because for example when you look at an object from different positions such as distance, the object is viewed in different sizes and shapes, and colors, etc, I believe that in this case his theory of perceiving is correct, because you will view the object differently from different Positions. The downs to his method in my opinion were his thoeries on the exsitence of God or people, i dont agree with his thoery were he proves Gods existence, or the way he proves peoples existence because of the similar or similar ways they perceive things. I understand the whole way of perceiving things, but not the way to prove God or People's existence, its seemed like his method cause more doubt than it actually proved things to be real.

Monday, May 11, 2009

Unit 8 Berkeley

1. Berkeley's thinking of perception and being, was that a person cant know an object to be real, they can only perceive the object. He believe that any object in the world is to be obtained only through perception.
2. Berkeley thought that the attempts to refer to "real" or "material" objects, was the way that a person perceived the matter. He belived that a person could not now any real or material objects, a person could only perceive the matter. He believed that the object a person perceives is the object that the person knows and experiences.
3. Berkeley's argument for the existence of other people is that, he believed that people were existent because they viewed the world just like him, which made them real or existent. He believed that since people would perceive things just like him, they existed and he believed since the people viewed the world just like him or in a similar way that the world was existent too.
4. Berkeley believed that if people had the same or similar perceptions of the world, than the people and the world were existent. He believed that if people viewed things that same as him or similar to him that they were existent.
5. Berkeley's view of God was, that God was real, he saw god as the infinite mind that perceives all. He belived that the reason he believed in something was because God had placed the idea in his mind, such as the example he uses in believing in the tree. He belived that God was real because he placed ideas in our mind so we could perceive things.
6. Dr Johnson tries to refute Berkeley by stating that the stone does exist, since he could feel it, hear it, and see it, he proclaimed that it did exist. But per Berkeley's theory if he could see it, feel it, and hear it, then her perceived that it was a stone. He belived that "ultimately it was an idea in his mind, nothing more, nothing less", he belived that it was only the way that Dr. Johnson perceived the object.
7. Locke's view of primary and secondary qualities are, solely dependent on the observer. Such as that when he uses the bucket of cold and hot water to determine that your hand state that the water is hot and cold, which in fact is not a quality of water. He believed that primary and secondary qualities solely depend on the observer.
8.As i stated earlier Locke's used the bucket of hot and cold water to argue this. By sticking one hand in the hot water, and then the other in cold, followed by sticking both hands in temperate water. He stated that since your hands tell you that the water is hot and cold, then the heat is not a quality of water.
9. Berkeley extends Locke's argument to primary qualities by stating that for example the size of an object will defer from one observer to the other because of the distance to the object, etc. Which one observers to the other wicll view the object as a different size. Therefor, since the size can vary from observer to observer, than size is not a quality of the object. This to my knowledge means that objects are perceived by individuals differently, which proves Berkeleys theory, that an individual perceives objects, and object cannot be said to be real, because people perceive objects through experience and their own ideas.
10. Well, it depends on who you are asking the question to, in my opinion if i do not perceive in god, than to me god is not existent, or is he?if i am perceiving that god is not existent, than he might exist because i am perceiving that he is not real. Now, If you ask Berkeley, he believed god exists because if he perceives in god, than god must have placed that idea in his mind.
11. If all the individuals perceive the same or in similar ways about the world or god, Then God is real, the world is real, and all these individuals are real. Per Berkeley's theory, if we perceive the same or similar than we are all existent, so i am assuming that if this theory is correct, the world is real, people are real, and God is real.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Unit 7 Decartes Part 3

18. In your own words, explain Cartesian dualism and how it gives rise to the mind-body problem.
It doesnt seem that the Cartesian Dualism worked at all, when you write you list of comparisons such as the engine and the car drice to the country side, it just does not add up correctly, because there is nothing in common . It seemd that Decartes focused to much on the mind, rather than the sorrounding, its almost like he didnt take into consideration the physical parts of the world, or vise versa too. The two elements of the Cartesian Dualism is the body and mind, when they are philosophized and compared to one another they do not add up or have anything in common. Decartes difinitions do not make sense, when you look at the mind and then look at the body they do not add up. I think Decartes may have tried to over think both areas more so than trying to think of a way to make both things work together. Its almost like Decartes should have chosen too either philosophize about the mind or the body, i think he went over his head.
19. In your own words, explain and evaluate Descartes's solution to the mind-body problem.
It seems that Decartes and i quote " Great Solution" was to tell the public/ philosophers that the body and mind work independent from each other, and most people believed that to be False. Most people agree that the body and mind can't function with out each other, they believe that both are needed to work. I believe Decartes solution is by far not the brightest thing he came up with, its almost like he spent so much time philosophyzing about the body and mind but when his system failed he just decided to throw a quick fix up out there. I am assuming that he was destroyed when his system failed to work, expecially when people rejected his not so bright solution. Non the less Decartes was a great philosopher because like most philosophers Decartes came up with his method as he went along, his method was created like an organized chain, like 1, 2, 3.
20. In your own words, explain and evaluate the arguments for and against physicalism (or materialism).
Physicalism means things that are existent or obvious such as matter and or objects, and Materialism are things that cant be proven and or are not felt such as Gods, etc. I think idealism is better than dualism, because ad we all know dualism failed to make th body and mind work. I think for Dualism both subjects should be able to work together, and i dont believe its true when Decartes stated that the body and mind do not work together. Physialism would be something that can be seen and felt, any object that can be seen or felt, when you can use your senses to prove an item, etc, etc.

Oddyssey 1 Galileo

Galileo’s is remembered as the Father of Philosophical Science. Galileo made the most important contributions to the philosophy of science. In Philosophy of science one must find a topic, find a hypothesis, and then examine it. Rather than using universals, or the scholastic method, we must prove or disprove topics by analysis and examination. In Philosophy of science, you do not let religion or any factor get in the way of obtaining true solid facts. Galileo was willing to face the government and most importantly religion, if it meant that he would obtain a solid theory. Modern day science is derived from Galileo’s Philosophy of science; to this day we still use the same steps of examination.
Galileo’s creation of the Philosophy of Science was created when the Philosophy of Universals and the religious Scholastic Method had failed to do the job. Using science to philosophize one can obtain a solid theory by analysis and testing. This method was a step forward to modern philosophy, for the first time religion and the natural world could be separated. This method allowed subjects to be tested with out having to incorporate religion into the examination and the results of the subject. This Method also gave way to the expansion of Mathematics; the Formula for PI was created by Galileo. This Method allowed you to use mathematics and science when testing the subjects.
Galileo’s ideas were genuine and astonishing. Through this method we are able to obtain intelligent results and theories with out having to satisfy religion. Even though at the time Galileo had so many religious and governmental enemies, he is now remember as one of the greatest scientist, philosophers, and mathematicians that ever lived. Galileo’s theories are true to human existence, because subjects are analyzed based on scientific methods whether the outcome is good or bad, they are not based on religion. Galileo’s arguments were strong in support and logic that most men of his time feared him. His method was very advanced for the time, that many times Galileo was order to stop by the government or the church.
The Creation of Philosophy of Science meant the destruction of the ancient philosophers. This method brought about all the modern thinkers and philosophers. This is the method that put a wall up and separated religion. Religion and Philosophy had not worked correctly in the past, and for the first time they did not need to interact with each other. There was not need to use the Scholastic method to make all analysis correct, or no need to use universals. This is what created the true philosopher; Philosophers would now challenge each other with out having to agree with each other. The Philosophy of Science challenged both the old and the new; it gave way to the new era of Philosophy.
Carlos Garcia
Modern Phil 202
March 26, 2009

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Unit 6 Decartes Part 2

11. Decartes Philosophical method was a lot like math, he used step by step reasoning for philosophical method. Decartes was from a time when philosophy had no set order, Decartes wanted to set an organized level of philosophy. There was also a diffenrence in Decartes method which did not derive from math and that was, that he did not want to assume anything. Decartes wanted to start out with something that had been proven certain then he would have a strong foundation to work with . Decartes wanted to build human kowledge to a foundation or absolute certainty, he found nothing at his time to have that absolute level of cetainty.
12. Decartes did not believe that our senses were the foundation of our knowledge, such as when he uses the piece of bee wax to demonstrate that we cant always use our senses for knowledge. Common sense would not meet the standard because at that point we would be assuming, or as Decartes says "The only other possible source for this knowledge is that it is innate".
13. Decartes did not belive that Mathematics could be the foundation to his method, because yes, with math you can achieve certainty but he believed that his senses would be fooling with him, even with the most simple operations. I really dont know how Decartes can use math for his foundation (kind of), and then not use it at all, it seems like most philosophers base their methods on one thing except for Decartes. Decartes seems annoying at times.
14. Cogito ergo sum, means i think therfore i exist. Decartes try to build a who method using this system, he believed that now he had the absolute certainty. Decartes once again used the mathematical system to lay out his reasoning, and he belived that once something is proven it becomes available as a foundation for other things. Like i mentioned earlier, for this system Decartes uses the bee wax to prove his theory. Decartes proves that one can't always depend on your senses, because they can prove us wrong and we could be assuming at that point.
15. With the Bee wax Decartes extablishes an innate idea, because your senses can always find the bee wax because of it look, texture and smell etc., but when the wax is melted the bee wax changes in appearance, smell, and texture, therefor if you assume that the melted liquid is still the original bee wax, then that would be an innate. An Innate idea means that not all sources can be derived from the senses.
16. Decartes believed that the concept of perfection would refer to a person who has no doubts or in other words God. The concept of perfection is the system Decartes uses to prove that god exists, he believed that perfection was derived from some one who he must have had some sort of contact with, and the only answer to that was God for him atleast. By using God he would prove that there is no evil genius.
17. Decartes proves the existence of the physical world by proving that god exsits through the concept of perfection, then by proving that he exists through Cogito ergo sum, and by providing that god exists he can prove that our senses are reliable, and then finally our senses prove the existence of the physical world. Decartes belives that there is in fact an external world because of the step process existence i just mentioned. It seems that before Decartes started analyzing he was doubting every thing, and then by using math like step by step analization he proved the existence of everything, and just like he said "once one thing is proven it can be used as the foundation for other things" and that is exactly what he did, he chained god, our existence, our senses, and the physical world.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Unit 5 Decartes

1. "I firmly believed that in this way I should much better succeed in the conduct of my life, than if I build only upon the old foundations, and leaned upon principles which, in my youth, I had taken on trust." I think this means that he would rather die doing what he believes true than living a life believing what tradition and religion say. He felt that he would live a much happier life knowing the true fact rather than the given history, even if it meant making many enemies.
2. The four precepts are; 1)"never to accept anything for true which I did not clearly know to be such"2)"divide each of the difficulties under examination into as many parts as possible"3)"conduct my thoughts in such order that, by commencing with objects the simplest and easiest to know, I might ascend by little and little, and, as it were, step by step, to the knowledge of the more complex" 4)"every case to make enumerations so complete, and reviews so general, that I might be assured that nothing was omitted"
3. the relationship between religion and the scientific method is almost as if they were enemies. Shorto made it seem like a war between Scientist and Religious folks, almost like the war will never end. You have liberals, and Conservatives fighting about views and ideas, Kind of like Modern USA, you have the religious south, and the liberal east and west coasts, then you have people that are in between kind of like the Northern Heart of the USA.
4. According to Shorto the great controversy continues is;"i think there for I am" which caused people to question basic beliefs, this became known as the foundation of modern science. The war between religion and the scientific method.
5. Religion was threatened by Decartes Method, People started doubting their basic beliefs, they began to question religion. Science began to disprove the religious faith through testing and analysis.
6. The Book Lady talks about a conflict between modernity and traditionalism. I believe that modernity would be the modern person who creates doubt and questions things, and the Traditionalism would be the person who follows the old ways and never doubts their Basic believes. Just liek when you compare the modern man and the modern Islamic man. Traditionalism in this case would be the old religious way, and modernism would be the Scientific method.
7. Shorto believed that in the proposal contained in "The Discourse on the Method for Rightly Conducting the Reason"; its almost like he agreed with the Discourse Method, almost like astonishment that a man could over throw 2000 years of history. He mentions how this open the door for modern science, medicine, politics, and society. He states how one could find truth in facts rather than relying on tradition or the Church's teachings.
8. I believe that if the Discourse Method had been written in Latin rather than in French, the out come would have been very different, Most people would have never heard of his methods because latin philosophers did not share their views with other people who werent philosophers. Its almost like Decartes wanted every one to see his method, like he wanted people to question and doubt the world. Decartes wanted people to know this, he didnt want to hide his views, even though he was facing danger by releasing the Discourse method.
9. Shorto's own interpretation of Descartes' importance in forming the modern world was; That his Method was the turning point of the world. He believed that the creation of the Scientific method meant the over throw of religion. It seems that Shorto was the most impressed with the saying "i think, there for i am". Shorto Believed that the Man who destroyed 2000 years of history was the man who layed the foundations to the modern world.
10. I know that Shorto was not a philosopher, but it seems that he was a man like you and myself who was influenced by a great philosopher. Though shorto was wrong many times, i believe he is the model of the modern human, who doubts and questions things. Though most men are not philosophers, we do all still question and think much like our great philophers. I would say that he represents the average man, with an average intelligence.

Monday, March 9, 2009

Unit 4 Hobbes

61. Hobbes believed that people were physical objects, he believed we were sophisticated machines all of whose functions and activities can be described and explained in purely mechanistic terms. Hobbes believed that everything we did could be explained in a mechanical way. One of the examples use is "Sensation involves a series of mechanical processes operating within the human nervous system" he was more supportive of Galileo's type of philosophy. The behaviors we should expect from unregulated human beings is; 1. we should expect men not carrying for any one but them selves, 2. men fighting for goods and resources, 3. State of War, Hobbes believed that there has to be a higher authority who governs and controls the actions of the people in order for there to be peace among the people. Hobbes model human being would be a person who can decided for himself, to decided what he thinks is best for him, to decided what actions he wants to take, and to decide what behavior or belives he wants to have.
62. Human Nature is related to Human behavior in the state of nature, because it involves a persons decisions and how they can affect a group of people as a whole. For example if a man decides to steal money to survive, this will affect a group of people. The actions that a person can take because of the their free will can affect that group of people. If there were no authorities or regulations you could expect a person to do what ever he wants with out caring if it affects other people, there would be war and crime if there werent any regulations. Hobbes believed that there needed to be regulations for the well being of the people. Regulations and authorities were needed in order to defend the freedom of all.
63. In the Founding of the commonwealth, people would loose certain freedoms, but they would also protect their freedoms by this system. Some of the things they would gain, would be less crime, for protection for societies, and peace. Hobbes knew that people would have to lose certain freedoms and rights in order to obtain a better life. Its almost like he believed in a modern government, kind of like a communist governement. Hobbes knew that people would not function if they were allowed total freedom, there would be many wars, high crime, society would not function as a whole, or you would have lords that would control the majority of the people by war, people would be slaves to a small majority, there would just be a lot of Chaos. By establishing a small government, people would enjoy more rights, and a better life, there would be a peaceful controlled society.
64.The Sovereign is involved in the social contract, because they are both part of the commonwealth, which means that a society would have one government and would have to give certain rights, and follow rules and regulations to have social order. A group of people united to form a social organization are the contracting parties in a social contract, along with a government. This type of social contract is called a commonwealth.
65.He believed that people would have to obey all the regulations that would be set. That they would try to maintain peace, and if a person were to do wrong he would be judged and punished. There were limits to a government, he belived that a person had the right to rise against the government, if he felt threatened. Thats he had the right to fight or over throw the system if he was endangered. Even though the government had total power, society could over throw the government if they felt that the government was abusing their power of not making the right decisions. Hobbes believed in Limits to Political Obligation.
66. Hobbes believed in a united commonwealth, he believed that if the power were devided in a commonwealth, that this would create problems, there would be a lot of conflict, and could even cause war. He thought that it would be easier for people to obey one government rather than many. Hobbes belived that a unified commonwealth was the best system, he believed that society would be more orderly and function correctly. Hobbes believed that by having a commonwealth that the rights and freedoms of the people would be protected.
67. Hobbes believed that the power of the common wealth shall not be limited, he believed that if the power was limited, the whole system would fail to accomplish its purpose. He believed that it would be a bad idead to limit or divide the common wealth, he felt that a lot of problems would arise if the commonwealth was limited or devided. He believed that private parties or religion could destroy the common wealth, if it were to be devided or limited.
Thanks,
Carlos Garcia

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Midterm

Midterm
1. From my understanding the Scholastic Method is taking two subjects, then analyzing and coming up with the differences between them, then analyzing the subjects again in a way where there are no differences. In other words making the differences agree with each other, making the differences all correct. I believe that the Scholastic Method is different from modern thinking, because for modern philosophy we will analyze and come with different or agreeing conclusions, we do not try to make the subjects differences agree with each other, we are not afraid to come up with differences or disproving subjects. I think that the scholastic method came about to cover all the flaws of religion texture and history, they did not want to have anything disprove religion. They believed that they could make the differeces agree with each other in a way to where they were both true.
6. Nicholas of Autrecourt stated that the attempt to continue to use Philosophical Reasoning to the Christian Doctrine had failed and needed to be abandoned. This was one of the stepping stones to ending the Scholastic Method, the Scholastic method was just too confusing and did not achieve its purpose. Hasdai Crescas, and Meister Eckhart Applied the rational method in order to make people understand that logic and faith were two different things, in order words that logic could not be applied to religion. A person would have to have faith and Believe in god, and logical reasoning would be used to analyze other subjects, This is how the Scholastic method began to die down and religion and philosophy began to seperate from each other. Nicholas, Crescas, and Eckhart were the Fathers of modernism, they showed the world the true colors of the Scholastic Method along with all its flaws.
7.The Method that Galileo rejected was the Method of going to authoritative texts to learn about nature. Galileos prefered method of inquiry would have been Observation and Mathematical sciences. Galileo was the father of mathematics and science, modern scientist use his observation and testing analysis to come up with theories and conclusions. Galileo Had many enemies because he was not afraid to challege any one, whether very educated, powerful or religious. I believe that his main enemy would have been the church, because he was not afraid to disprove religion, he believed that by obsevation and testing one could come up with a conclusion, in other words Scientifical Philosophy, he was willing to stand up to any one regardeless of status, he is the father of scientifical Philosophy. I believe that his views and ideas would be aimed more towards modern philosophy, because many scientist still use his scientifical philosophy, and to this day we still use his mathematical formulas such as Pi(3.14).
10. Bacon's Ideas of nature were things that make up the world that could be said to be real by using our senses, such as sight, hearing, feel, taste. Bacon's Ideas of forms are things that cannot be physically seen but are know to be real or exist. These ideas are related to the logic structure of modern science, because just like scientist there are things that cannot be seen but that are know to be existent. Or just like modern science there are things that can be seen or felt or heard, such as the sun, or the moon, or water. In modern science there are things that cannot be tested and only seen such as the stars, which scientist conclude are still real. Just like Galileo, Bacon is one of the fathers of scientifical philosophy.
13. It seems like all the transitional thinkers that moved us into modern philosophy had observation, mathematics, and science in common. It seems that Scientifical Philosophy is what really got us into modern times. But there is also one thing that seems to have crossed each transitional thinkers mind in one way or another, this actually might be the right answer rather than Scientifical Phil., and that would be Religion. It seems that one way or another Religion always crossed every ones way, whether good or bad. It seems like a lot of this modern thinking was derived from religion, just like Galileo annoying the church with his analysis, etc. It seems that religion always played a huge part in bringing us into the modern world, and even today religion and modern thinkers do not agree most of the time. Its almost like a war between modern thinkers and ancient religion.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Unit 3 Francis Bacon

1. Bacons meaning of nature differs from that of the Old Scholastic method, For Bacon Natures mean and i quote"the natural phenomena of heat, sound, light, or of any other actual object of the investigations of physical science"
2. Bacon's meanin of Forms to differs from the old Scholastic method, For Bacon Forms mean and i quote again "Forms are the immanent laws of these natures". It seems that Bacon used science as his main method to philosophy.
3. Bacons idol of tribe consist in thinking of things and their relations by analogy with man. this means that although the subject did not exist and was fully made up in a way by the human mind, that is was still analized and used as a method of philosophy. In other words even though that is was not true or existent in any way, it was still used with out having proof or evidence of its reality ( it was complete made up or created by the Human Mind)
4. Bacon's Idols of the Cave consist of the psychic formation of the individual, This one lost me a little. To my knowledge i understood that a person was judged by his existence, things that he had done in his life, or the people that sorrounded him. The Philosophical method included the things the person did in life, the language he spoke, the intelligence the person had, the books read, and the people that sorrounded him ( i assume family and Frieds). It seems that the persons spirit/ doings in life where taken into consideration for the method of philosophy.
5. Bacon's Idols of the Marketplace consist of the intercourse and association of men with each other, To my understanding men were judged by the way they spoke to the public or the type of language they used. For example people were judged if they had poor or ill mannered languages, or vice versa, they were judged for being well or properly spoken. I also understood that men were also judged by the norm, the way people around him spoke, kind of like the norm around the person.
6. Bacon's Idols of the Theatre consist of Idols which have immigrated into men's minds from the various dogmas of philosophies, and also from wrong laws of demonstration, to my knowledge this means that people were also judged by things/ forces that had changed the way the person is, in a way things that had made the person do what he did or change his point of views. It seemed that Men were judged by factors in life that may have changed a person mind, such as the public, knowledge, or other factors in life. For this method they talk about comparing different plays, i think this means that every person is around different types of languages, itelligence, publics, and other factors that will change the outcome of the persons physical mind and spirit.
7. Bacon's table of presence consist of lists all the cases wherein the phenomenon exists whose formal cause is sought, This seems to be a scientific method of Philosophy, for one of the examples they use heat realeased from a fire or the sun. To my knowledge things were proven or judged using scientific data, such at the most common things life heat from a fire or the sun, and cold from ice or wind. I think that the most common elements were used to Philosophy or analyze the subject.
8. Bacon's table of absence consist of lists all the cases in which the phenomenon under analysis does not appear to be present, To my Knowledge for the method of philosophy the subject was analyzed or judged with out having firm proof or evidence of the existence of the thing. for example they use stars as being existent but not having any heat. Which in my opinion it means if it can be seen but cannot be proven to be real, then it is real. Almost like if you can see it than it is real with out having to be scientifically proven, due to being almost impossible to test these natural things.
9. Bacon's table of degrees consist of lists the increase and decrease of the given phenomenon in one object or in different objects, To my knowledge this means that the subject was tested using scientific philosophy. The Philosopher would create an experiment and a hypothesis to best test the subject, this meand that the philopher would come up with the best answer to the subject, though sometimes it would be very limited. This is where the laws of science come into play to analyze the subject.
10. The Baconian Method to my knowleged is a method of putting lists together to best analyze and judge/test the subject. As we have discussed in the earlier questions there were a few methods to put these lists together with. For example it seems that every thing was scientifically analyzes whether it could be tested or not. For Example they use the stars as being real but producing no heat which means that they cannot be tested but are known to be true, then they use the sun and fire as realeasing heat which can be tested to be true and existent. This methos had a few similarities with the Scholastic method because it used the different methods of philosophy to come up with various ideas, then all the ideas were put together to derrive with the best idea, in away all the ideas even if different just like the scholastic method were made to agree with each other or to all be considered true in a way. The non existent/ non proven items were compared with the existent/ proven items to derive with the final conclusion.
11. What Bacon found lacking in Aristotle was the use of general theory of science, which he belived could be applied to all branches of natural history and philosophy. I think that Artisoles methods had become to primitive compareds to Bacons method. I think Bacon Became for scientific that his previous greek philosphers. Though in my opinion it seems that Aristotle's methods were in a way the stepping stones for Bacon's scientific philosophical methods.
12. Bacons Methods are similar to modern scientifc philosophy, because just like Bacon subjects are tested with the creation of a hypothesis. It the subject can be tested than it will be tested and analyzed to come up with the best conclusion. In modern science things such as stars that can be seen are known to be true even though they cant be tested or experimented. It seems that our modern Scientific Philosophy was derived from Bacons Methods.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Unit 2 Galileo

1. Ockham is described as a nomalist, because he viewed things more simpler than the older philosophers, like in the example that is uses in the literare and Quote " if the button is red and the other button is red there is only our own mental act that notices the resemblence in color". He belived that things that are obvious, or he states " concrete substances" are real, and that all the other views and ideas were created by the human mind. Though his ideas are still not up to Par with modern Philosophy, it seems like Ockman views are some of the stepping stones of Modern philosophy. Though his ideas were different, he still belived that God was Universal.
2. Ockman's Razor meant that things were defended more simpler, meaning that you dont find hidden meanins or different view to defend the subject. For example what you see is what it is, and there is nothing more to it. In other words the subject needed to be defended with existing entities, things that you and i know are simple true.
3. Ockman's razor would differ greatly to the problem of Universals, Because Ockmans Razor would pretty much silence the belief of universals, stating if i cant see it then it doesnt exist. Ockman's razor and the belief of Universal would have conflicted all the time, because in Universals you find a way to make disagreements agree with each other, or find hidden meanings or ideas that are not obvious. Ockman's razor was strict and firm, meaning if the evidence is not there than it does not exist.
4. Ockman's mere belief meant that all universals were not real but only created by the human mind, meaning that they had no existence past some one's mind. Though he did believe that God was universal and true, that nothing was needed to prove his existence, Ockman's Razor did not apply to him.
5. Ockmans Idea that was of great importance to British Philosophy in my opinion would have to be Parsimony "Ockmans razor" which led to the least complicated way of solving things, which was a great method when solving hypothesis. It made things a lot easier to prove and support, with out having to find alternate idead, view, universals.
6. Nicholas of Autrecourt stated that the efforts to apply philosophical meaning have failed and should be abandoned. I believe that this gave way to modernism, because for the firt time religion did not have to be part of different views, and ideas. Things could be proven with out having to make religion and the subject work out.
7. Hasdai Crescas began to seperate religion and human knowledge. This meant that human knowledge and religion could be used to analyze things, it was not as limited or finite as Ockman's system of philosophy.
8. Nicolas of Cusa tried to save Scholatism by stating that Just like God, we must find the subject true with out reasoning its logic, I dont think this worked out, because philosophers with the new movement to modernism has more freedon to analyze and support their subjects, they were not as limited as with Ockmans system.
9. In my Opinion it seemed that Galileo rejected the religious method of inquiry. though he has Very religious he did not mix philosophical and religious means with his science. He believed in testing in proving things, things could not be true if not proved or seen.
10. Galileo's method of inquiry was scientifical, he did not use religion or philosophy, He belived that every thing could be proven by using mathematics or my scientifically proving it.
11. I think Galileo had so many enemies because a lot of his scientific methods would wrong certain aspects of religion or the way that ancient man had always seen the world.
12. Galileo is rembered as the father of modern philosophy of science
13. Galileos most important contributions to the philosophy of science, were that he was willing to change the ways people viewed the world, he found it easier to prove things by using science rather than universals or religion.
14. The Aristoleans did not like the Pi formula, they did not want Galileo to teach any one the PI formula, they banned him from going around and teaching his theories and formulas.
15. The Aristoleans thinking differes from modern thinking, because they involved the church in philosophy , that is the reason for why the philosophy of science was a threat to them, they did not like the fact that Galileo's science challenged and threatened the church, and even though Galileo was catholic we was not afraid to prove any subjects.
16. Galileo was wrong about the comets because he critized The Mathematical author with out proving the author wrong, he did not use scientifical methods, instead he ridiculed the Author.
17. Galileo said that 2 objects with different masses if not interupted will fall at the same rate, as ancient men thought that the heavier the object the faster it will fall. Galileo theory aided in the testing of gravity.
18. Galileos' theories of tides were that the earth revolved around the sun, he tested the high tides and found out that each high tide different by 12 hours.
19. Galileo's theory of tides was wrong because he did not belive that the moon caused tides, he belived that the sun caused the tides
20. Galileo's theory of tides is a rapid departure from the scholastic method, because with his scientific method he did not try to make the disagreements agree with each, in other words both make sense and work together. He challeged that other scientist and stated that the other scientist was wrong with out using the scholastic method, in other words you are either right or wrong there is no 2 right answers.
Thanks,
Carlos Garcia

Sunday, January 25, 2009

1. What is the scholastic method? From what i read my understanding is that the scholastic way is a way to understand and critizise the literature of an author. for example they talk about how the students would read the literature carefully and would learn to appreciate the thoughts of the author. It also states that there was 2 steps of analizing the literature, one of the steps was Philological analysis which means that you would try to find hidden meanings in certain words, you would try to look for words that the author could have used that have other meaning rather than the logical realistic meanings. Then comes the second step which is called the Logical analysis, during the logical analysis you read the literature and analyze it using regular logic, or in other words putting together the thoughts of the author exactly the way its written with no hidden meanings or uses in the litterature. It also States that Anselm was one of the Philosophers that contributed to he Scholastic Method, this was started in an effort to defend and support his religious beliefs.
2. What are “sententiae” and how did they figure in the scholasticmethod? The sententiae were used as the points of disagreement and contention, they were a few sentences that were wirtten to describe the different sources. From the reading it states that the disagreement and contentions in the Sententiae would be written out in a way where the two sides would be in agreement, this process of evaluation took 2 days to be completed.
3. What was the aim of the scholastic method? What were they trying todo? to my understanding it seems that this method enabled people to analyze and view things in 2 ways, rather than just one. in other words it made you think in and outside the box. For example you would analize the literature in a logical way word by word, then you would analyze it again and try to find hidden meanings in words or in sentences. I dont like the idea that alot of this method was derrived from religion, it seems like it was used to cover up a lot of the flaws of the religious literature, i dont understand why you would have to undertand an author logically and Philologically. To me it seems like the philosophers would use those 2 methods so that they could pick the best qualities that are in the favor either by choosing some of the views and ideas logically or Philologically.
4. What was “philology” and how did the scholastics use it? Like i have stated before in my opinion Philology was used to find hidden meanings in literature, or analyze words that the author may have used to portray a different ideas.
5. For the scholastics, what was the purpose of logical analysis? The purpose was to analyze an authors literature logically word by word, in other words their ideas would be represented by exactly what it would mean to a regular person if they read it, with no hidden views or ideas.

7.hat did Bonaventure think was our relationship to God? Bonaventure thought that every thing revolved aroung God, and that God was at the center of everything because he had created everything. He believed that everything could be derived by religious faith, He though that views an ideas could be reached by having faith. in other words nothing could be argued or analyzed before using religious faith as an instrument.
8. What did Aquinas think is the right relationship between faith andreason? Aquinas believed that is was possible to support religius beliefs and ideas. He believed that it was possble to prove that there was a God and that religion could incorporate the new teachings of the modern philosophers, In other words he believed that the new and the old religious beliefs could mesh and be considered to be true. He believed that there were steps to defend and prove that there was a god, he found ways to defend religion from modern thinkers. He developed a system for 5 ways to prove the existence of God.
9. How would Aquinas respond to a situation in which reasoncontradicted faith? He would probably try to incorporate the contradiction into his reasoning to probe that religion is true. In other words he would probably use the contradiction to his favor, some how he would make it a part of his religious reasoning to satisfy both his religious belief and the reasoning od the other party.
10. State the problem of universals in your own words. It seems that Universals caused a major problem because different groups with different beliefs emerged, making it harder for some one to agree in just one idea. These new groups that formed all had different views and ideas about things, in other words this caused more chaos because it made it harder to agree on just one thing. This made people dispute and support views and ideas in different ways.
11. Describe “realism” in your own words. Its the way that universals exist, For example one of the methods is Platonic realism which means that real entities exist independently from all other things, and then their is Nominalism realism which mean the certain entities exist depending on other things. It is two ways to analyze some thing for example one may think that one thing can only exist if another thing exists, or we may say that the thing can exist solely on itself with out having to depend on the existence of another thing.
12. Describe “nominalism” in your own words. Nominalism denies that universals are real, they belive that only individuals exist, and that Nominalism can account for all the relevant things that happen. They dont agree or believe in the ideas of realism because they believe that realism causes too many problems. It is the exact opposite of Realism.
testing testing

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

hello.
helloe
hello