Saturday, February 28, 2009

Midterm

Midterm
1. From my understanding the Scholastic Method is taking two subjects, then analyzing and coming up with the differences between them, then analyzing the subjects again in a way where there are no differences. In other words making the differences agree with each other, making the differences all correct. I believe that the Scholastic Method is different from modern thinking, because for modern philosophy we will analyze and come with different or agreeing conclusions, we do not try to make the subjects differences agree with each other, we are not afraid to come up with differences or disproving subjects. I think that the scholastic method came about to cover all the flaws of religion texture and history, they did not want to have anything disprove religion. They believed that they could make the differeces agree with each other in a way to where they were both true.
6. Nicholas of Autrecourt stated that the attempt to continue to use Philosophical Reasoning to the Christian Doctrine had failed and needed to be abandoned. This was one of the stepping stones to ending the Scholastic Method, the Scholastic method was just too confusing and did not achieve its purpose. Hasdai Crescas, and Meister Eckhart Applied the rational method in order to make people understand that logic and faith were two different things, in order words that logic could not be applied to religion. A person would have to have faith and Believe in god, and logical reasoning would be used to analyze other subjects, This is how the Scholastic method began to die down and religion and philosophy began to seperate from each other. Nicholas, Crescas, and Eckhart were the Fathers of modernism, they showed the world the true colors of the Scholastic Method along with all its flaws.
7.The Method that Galileo rejected was the Method of going to authoritative texts to learn about nature. Galileos prefered method of inquiry would have been Observation and Mathematical sciences. Galileo was the father of mathematics and science, modern scientist use his observation and testing analysis to come up with theories and conclusions. Galileo Had many enemies because he was not afraid to challege any one, whether very educated, powerful or religious. I believe that his main enemy would have been the church, because he was not afraid to disprove religion, he believed that by obsevation and testing one could come up with a conclusion, in other words Scientifical Philosophy, he was willing to stand up to any one regardeless of status, he is the father of scientifical Philosophy. I believe that his views and ideas would be aimed more towards modern philosophy, because many scientist still use his scientifical philosophy, and to this day we still use his mathematical formulas such as Pi(3.14).
10. Bacon's Ideas of nature were things that make up the world that could be said to be real by using our senses, such as sight, hearing, feel, taste. Bacon's Ideas of forms are things that cannot be physically seen but are know to be real or exist. These ideas are related to the logic structure of modern science, because just like scientist there are things that cannot be seen but that are know to be existent. Or just like modern science there are things that can be seen or felt or heard, such as the sun, or the moon, or water. In modern science there are things that cannot be tested and only seen such as the stars, which scientist conclude are still real. Just like Galileo, Bacon is one of the fathers of scientifical philosophy.
13. It seems like all the transitional thinkers that moved us into modern philosophy had observation, mathematics, and science in common. It seems that Scientifical Philosophy is what really got us into modern times. But there is also one thing that seems to have crossed each transitional thinkers mind in one way or another, this actually might be the right answer rather than Scientifical Phil., and that would be Religion. It seems that one way or another Religion always crossed every ones way, whether good or bad. It seems like a lot of this modern thinking was derived from religion, just like Galileo annoying the church with his analysis, etc. It seems that religion always played a huge part in bringing us into the modern world, and even today religion and modern thinkers do not agree most of the time. Its almost like a war between modern thinkers and ancient religion.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Unit 3 Francis Bacon

1. Bacons meaning of nature differs from that of the Old Scholastic method, For Bacon Natures mean and i quote"the natural phenomena of heat, sound, light, or of any other actual object of the investigations of physical science"
2. Bacon's meanin of Forms to differs from the old Scholastic method, For Bacon Forms mean and i quote again "Forms are the immanent laws of these natures". It seems that Bacon used science as his main method to philosophy.
3. Bacons idol of tribe consist in thinking of things and their relations by analogy with man. this means that although the subject did not exist and was fully made up in a way by the human mind, that is was still analized and used as a method of philosophy. In other words even though that is was not true or existent in any way, it was still used with out having proof or evidence of its reality ( it was complete made up or created by the Human Mind)
4. Bacon's Idols of the Cave consist of the psychic formation of the individual, This one lost me a little. To my knowledge i understood that a person was judged by his existence, things that he had done in his life, or the people that sorrounded him. The Philosophical method included the things the person did in life, the language he spoke, the intelligence the person had, the books read, and the people that sorrounded him ( i assume family and Frieds). It seems that the persons spirit/ doings in life where taken into consideration for the method of philosophy.
5. Bacon's Idols of the Marketplace consist of the intercourse and association of men with each other, To my understanding men were judged by the way they spoke to the public or the type of language they used. For example people were judged if they had poor or ill mannered languages, or vice versa, they were judged for being well or properly spoken. I also understood that men were also judged by the norm, the way people around him spoke, kind of like the norm around the person.
6. Bacon's Idols of the Theatre consist of Idols which have immigrated into men's minds from the various dogmas of philosophies, and also from wrong laws of demonstration, to my knowledge this means that people were also judged by things/ forces that had changed the way the person is, in a way things that had made the person do what he did or change his point of views. It seemed that Men were judged by factors in life that may have changed a person mind, such as the public, knowledge, or other factors in life. For this method they talk about comparing different plays, i think this means that every person is around different types of languages, itelligence, publics, and other factors that will change the outcome of the persons physical mind and spirit.
7. Bacon's table of presence consist of lists all the cases wherein the phenomenon exists whose formal cause is sought, This seems to be a scientific method of Philosophy, for one of the examples they use heat realeased from a fire or the sun. To my knowledge things were proven or judged using scientific data, such at the most common things life heat from a fire or the sun, and cold from ice or wind. I think that the most common elements were used to Philosophy or analyze the subject.
8. Bacon's table of absence consist of lists all the cases in which the phenomenon under analysis does not appear to be present, To my Knowledge for the method of philosophy the subject was analyzed or judged with out having firm proof or evidence of the existence of the thing. for example they use stars as being existent but not having any heat. Which in my opinion it means if it can be seen but cannot be proven to be real, then it is real. Almost like if you can see it than it is real with out having to be scientifically proven, due to being almost impossible to test these natural things.
9. Bacon's table of degrees consist of lists the increase and decrease of the given phenomenon in one object or in different objects, To my knowledge this means that the subject was tested using scientific philosophy. The Philosopher would create an experiment and a hypothesis to best test the subject, this meand that the philopher would come up with the best answer to the subject, though sometimes it would be very limited. This is where the laws of science come into play to analyze the subject.
10. The Baconian Method to my knowleged is a method of putting lists together to best analyze and judge/test the subject. As we have discussed in the earlier questions there were a few methods to put these lists together with. For example it seems that every thing was scientifically analyzes whether it could be tested or not. For Example they use the stars as being real but producing no heat which means that they cannot be tested but are known to be true, then they use the sun and fire as realeasing heat which can be tested to be true and existent. This methos had a few similarities with the Scholastic method because it used the different methods of philosophy to come up with various ideas, then all the ideas were put together to derrive with the best idea, in away all the ideas even if different just like the scholastic method were made to agree with each other or to all be considered true in a way. The non existent/ non proven items were compared with the existent/ proven items to derive with the final conclusion.
11. What Bacon found lacking in Aristotle was the use of general theory of science, which he belived could be applied to all branches of natural history and philosophy. I think that Artisoles methods had become to primitive compareds to Bacons method. I think Bacon Became for scientific that his previous greek philosphers. Though in my opinion it seems that Aristotle's methods were in a way the stepping stones for Bacon's scientific philosophical methods.
12. Bacons Methods are similar to modern scientifc philosophy, because just like Bacon subjects are tested with the creation of a hypothesis. It the subject can be tested than it will be tested and analyzed to come up with the best conclusion. In modern science things such as stars that can be seen are known to be true even though they cant be tested or experimented. It seems that our modern Scientific Philosophy was derived from Bacons Methods.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Unit 2 Galileo

1. Ockham is described as a nomalist, because he viewed things more simpler than the older philosophers, like in the example that is uses in the literare and Quote " if the button is red and the other button is red there is only our own mental act that notices the resemblence in color". He belived that things that are obvious, or he states " concrete substances" are real, and that all the other views and ideas were created by the human mind. Though his ideas are still not up to Par with modern Philosophy, it seems like Ockman views are some of the stepping stones of Modern philosophy. Though his ideas were different, he still belived that God was Universal.
2. Ockman's Razor meant that things were defended more simpler, meaning that you dont find hidden meanins or different view to defend the subject. For example what you see is what it is, and there is nothing more to it. In other words the subject needed to be defended with existing entities, things that you and i know are simple true.
3. Ockman's razor would differ greatly to the problem of Universals, Because Ockmans Razor would pretty much silence the belief of universals, stating if i cant see it then it doesnt exist. Ockman's razor and the belief of Universal would have conflicted all the time, because in Universals you find a way to make disagreements agree with each other, or find hidden meanings or ideas that are not obvious. Ockman's razor was strict and firm, meaning if the evidence is not there than it does not exist.
4. Ockman's mere belief meant that all universals were not real but only created by the human mind, meaning that they had no existence past some one's mind. Though he did believe that God was universal and true, that nothing was needed to prove his existence, Ockman's Razor did not apply to him.
5. Ockmans Idea that was of great importance to British Philosophy in my opinion would have to be Parsimony "Ockmans razor" which led to the least complicated way of solving things, which was a great method when solving hypothesis. It made things a lot easier to prove and support, with out having to find alternate idead, view, universals.
6. Nicholas of Autrecourt stated that the efforts to apply philosophical meaning have failed and should be abandoned. I believe that this gave way to modernism, because for the firt time religion did not have to be part of different views, and ideas. Things could be proven with out having to make religion and the subject work out.
7. Hasdai Crescas began to seperate religion and human knowledge. This meant that human knowledge and religion could be used to analyze things, it was not as limited or finite as Ockman's system of philosophy.
8. Nicolas of Cusa tried to save Scholatism by stating that Just like God, we must find the subject true with out reasoning its logic, I dont think this worked out, because philosophers with the new movement to modernism has more freedon to analyze and support their subjects, they were not as limited as with Ockmans system.
9. In my Opinion it seemed that Galileo rejected the religious method of inquiry. though he has Very religious he did not mix philosophical and religious means with his science. He believed in testing in proving things, things could not be true if not proved or seen.
10. Galileo's method of inquiry was scientifical, he did not use religion or philosophy, He belived that every thing could be proven by using mathematics or my scientifically proving it.
11. I think Galileo had so many enemies because a lot of his scientific methods would wrong certain aspects of religion or the way that ancient man had always seen the world.
12. Galileo is rembered as the father of modern philosophy of science
13. Galileos most important contributions to the philosophy of science, were that he was willing to change the ways people viewed the world, he found it easier to prove things by using science rather than universals or religion.
14. The Aristoleans did not like the Pi formula, they did not want Galileo to teach any one the PI formula, they banned him from going around and teaching his theories and formulas.
15. The Aristoleans thinking differes from modern thinking, because they involved the church in philosophy , that is the reason for why the philosophy of science was a threat to them, they did not like the fact that Galileo's science challenged and threatened the church, and even though Galileo was catholic we was not afraid to prove any subjects.
16. Galileo was wrong about the comets because he critized The Mathematical author with out proving the author wrong, he did not use scientifical methods, instead he ridiculed the Author.
17. Galileo said that 2 objects with different masses if not interupted will fall at the same rate, as ancient men thought that the heavier the object the faster it will fall. Galileo theory aided in the testing of gravity.
18. Galileos' theories of tides were that the earth revolved around the sun, he tested the high tides and found out that each high tide different by 12 hours.
19. Galileo's theory of tides was wrong because he did not belive that the moon caused tides, he belived that the sun caused the tides
20. Galileo's theory of tides is a rapid departure from the scholastic method, because with his scientific method he did not try to make the disagreements agree with each, in other words both make sense and work together. He challeged that other scientist and stated that the other scientist was wrong with out using the scholastic method, in other words you are either right or wrong there is no 2 right answers.
Thanks,
Carlos Garcia