Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Unit 5 Decartes

1. "I firmly believed that in this way I should much better succeed in the conduct of my life, than if I build only upon the old foundations, and leaned upon principles which, in my youth, I had taken on trust." I think this means that he would rather die doing what he believes true than living a life believing what tradition and religion say. He felt that he would live a much happier life knowing the true fact rather than the given history, even if it meant making many enemies.
2. The four precepts are; 1)"never to accept anything for true which I did not clearly know to be such"2)"divide each of the difficulties under examination into as many parts as possible"3)"conduct my thoughts in such order that, by commencing with objects the simplest and easiest to know, I might ascend by little and little, and, as it were, step by step, to the knowledge of the more complex" 4)"every case to make enumerations so complete, and reviews so general, that I might be assured that nothing was omitted"
3. the relationship between religion and the scientific method is almost as if they were enemies. Shorto made it seem like a war between Scientist and Religious folks, almost like the war will never end. You have liberals, and Conservatives fighting about views and ideas, Kind of like Modern USA, you have the religious south, and the liberal east and west coasts, then you have people that are in between kind of like the Northern Heart of the USA.
4. According to Shorto the great controversy continues is;"i think there for I am" which caused people to question basic beliefs, this became known as the foundation of modern science. The war between religion and the scientific method.
5. Religion was threatened by Decartes Method, People started doubting their basic beliefs, they began to question religion. Science began to disprove the religious faith through testing and analysis.
6. The Book Lady talks about a conflict between modernity and traditionalism. I believe that modernity would be the modern person who creates doubt and questions things, and the Traditionalism would be the person who follows the old ways and never doubts their Basic believes. Just liek when you compare the modern man and the modern Islamic man. Traditionalism in this case would be the old religious way, and modernism would be the Scientific method.
7. Shorto believed that in the proposal contained in "The Discourse on the Method for Rightly Conducting the Reason"; its almost like he agreed with the Discourse Method, almost like astonishment that a man could over throw 2000 years of history. He mentions how this open the door for modern science, medicine, politics, and society. He states how one could find truth in facts rather than relying on tradition or the Church's teachings.
8. I believe that if the Discourse Method had been written in Latin rather than in French, the out come would have been very different, Most people would have never heard of his methods because latin philosophers did not share their views with other people who werent philosophers. Its almost like Decartes wanted every one to see his method, like he wanted people to question and doubt the world. Decartes wanted people to know this, he didnt want to hide his views, even though he was facing danger by releasing the Discourse method.
9. Shorto's own interpretation of Descartes' importance in forming the modern world was; That his Method was the turning point of the world. He believed that the creation of the Scientific method meant the over throw of religion. It seems that Shorto was the most impressed with the saying "i think, there for i am". Shorto Believed that the Man who destroyed 2000 years of history was the man who layed the foundations to the modern world.
10. I know that Shorto was not a philosopher, but it seems that he was a man like you and myself who was influenced by a great philosopher. Though shorto was wrong many times, i believe he is the model of the modern human, who doubts and questions things. Though most men are not philosophers, we do all still question and think much like our great philophers. I would say that he represents the average man, with an average intelligence.

1 comment:

  1. I like the way you interpret the quote. Descartes's rejection of tradition in terms of knowledge is the bit that Wikipedia misses.

    Shorto is mistaken if he thinks that "I think therefore I am" is the basis of the scientific method. In actual fact, "I think therefore I am" did not go anywhere, and did not provide a basis for anything.

    Overall, you've got pretty much everything right, and I very much like the way you put things. Well done.

    ReplyDelete