Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Unit 7 Decartes Part 3

18. In your own words, explain Cartesian dualism and how it gives rise to the mind-body problem.
It doesnt seem that the Cartesian Dualism worked at all, when you write you list of comparisons such as the engine and the car drice to the country side, it just does not add up correctly, because there is nothing in common . It seemd that Decartes focused to much on the mind, rather than the sorrounding, its almost like he didnt take into consideration the physical parts of the world, or vise versa too. The two elements of the Cartesian Dualism is the body and mind, when they are philosophized and compared to one another they do not add up or have anything in common. Decartes difinitions do not make sense, when you look at the mind and then look at the body they do not add up. I think Decartes may have tried to over think both areas more so than trying to think of a way to make both things work together. Its almost like Decartes should have chosen too either philosophize about the mind or the body, i think he went over his head.
19. In your own words, explain and evaluate Descartes's solution to the mind-body problem.
It seems that Decartes and i quote " Great Solution" was to tell the public/ philosophers that the body and mind work independent from each other, and most people believed that to be False. Most people agree that the body and mind can't function with out each other, they believe that both are needed to work. I believe Decartes solution is by far not the brightest thing he came up with, its almost like he spent so much time philosophyzing about the body and mind but when his system failed he just decided to throw a quick fix up out there. I am assuming that he was destroyed when his system failed to work, expecially when people rejected his not so bright solution. Non the less Decartes was a great philosopher because like most philosophers Decartes came up with his method as he went along, his method was created like an organized chain, like 1, 2, 3.
20. In your own words, explain and evaluate the arguments for and against physicalism (or materialism).
Physicalism means things that are existent or obvious such as matter and or objects, and Materialism are things that cant be proven and or are not felt such as Gods, etc. I think idealism is better than dualism, because ad we all know dualism failed to make th body and mind work. I think for Dualism both subjects should be able to work together, and i dont believe its true when Decartes stated that the body and mind do not work together. Physialism would be something that can be seen and felt, any object that can be seen or felt, when you can use your senses to prove an item, etc, etc.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Carlos,

    I'm giving you 18/20 because you really did not come to grips with any of Descartes's central ideas or arguments.

    The fact that the concept of mind has nothing in common with the concept of body is the point Descartes is trying to make. Descartes argues that since the two concepts have nothing in common, the existence of that mind is completely independent of the existence of the body. Also, you do not explain what the mind-body problem is, or how Cartesian dualism leads to the mind-body problem. Descartes solution was to claim that mind and body interacted through the pineal gland. This did not work because the mind-body problem concerns _how_ mind and body can interact when they have no qualities in common, not _where_ they interact.

    Your definition of "materialism" actually applies to idealism. Materialism denies that things like gods exist. Materialism says that only material things exist. Physicalism says that the only things that exist are things that obey physical law.

    ReplyDelete