Monday, May 11, 2009

Unit 8 Berkeley

1. Berkeley's thinking of perception and being, was that a person cant know an object to be real, they can only perceive the object. He believe that any object in the world is to be obtained only through perception.
2. Berkeley thought that the attempts to refer to "real" or "material" objects, was the way that a person perceived the matter. He belived that a person could not now any real or material objects, a person could only perceive the matter. He believed that the object a person perceives is the object that the person knows and experiences.
3. Berkeley's argument for the existence of other people is that, he believed that people were existent because they viewed the world just like him, which made them real or existent. He believed that since people would perceive things just like him, they existed and he believed since the people viewed the world just like him or in a similar way that the world was existent too.
4. Berkeley believed that if people had the same or similar perceptions of the world, than the people and the world were existent. He believed that if people viewed things that same as him or similar to him that they were existent.
5. Berkeley's view of God was, that God was real, he saw god as the infinite mind that perceives all. He belived that the reason he believed in something was because God had placed the idea in his mind, such as the example he uses in believing in the tree. He belived that God was real because he placed ideas in our mind so we could perceive things.
6. Dr Johnson tries to refute Berkeley by stating that the stone does exist, since he could feel it, hear it, and see it, he proclaimed that it did exist. But per Berkeley's theory if he could see it, feel it, and hear it, then her perceived that it was a stone. He belived that "ultimately it was an idea in his mind, nothing more, nothing less", he belived that it was only the way that Dr. Johnson perceived the object.
7. Locke's view of primary and secondary qualities are, solely dependent on the observer. Such as that when he uses the bucket of cold and hot water to determine that your hand state that the water is hot and cold, which in fact is not a quality of water. He believed that primary and secondary qualities solely depend on the observer.
8.As i stated earlier Locke's used the bucket of hot and cold water to argue this. By sticking one hand in the hot water, and then the other in cold, followed by sticking both hands in temperate water. He stated that since your hands tell you that the water is hot and cold, then the heat is not a quality of water.
9. Berkeley extends Locke's argument to primary qualities by stating that for example the size of an object will defer from one observer to the other because of the distance to the object, etc. Which one observers to the other wicll view the object as a different size. Therefor, since the size can vary from observer to observer, than size is not a quality of the object. This to my knowledge means that objects are perceived by individuals differently, which proves Berkeleys theory, that an individual perceives objects, and object cannot be said to be real, because people perceive objects through experience and their own ideas.
10. Well, it depends on who you are asking the question to, in my opinion if i do not perceive in god, than to me god is not existent, or is he?if i am perceiving that god is not existent, than he might exist because i am perceiving that he is not real. Now, If you ask Berkeley, he believed god exists because if he perceives in god, than god must have placed that idea in his mind.
11. If all the individuals perceive the same or in similar ways about the world or god, Then God is real, the world is real, and all these individuals are real. Per Berkeley's theory, if we perceive the same or similar than we are all existent, so i am assuming that if this theory is correct, the world is real, people are real, and God is real.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Carlos.

    I think you have very good handle on Berkeley. However, he thinks that people exist because he perceives them, and they perceive each other, not because they perceive things the same way he does.

    Berkeley believed that things continued to exist even when no human was perceiving them because god continued to perceive them even when no one else did.

    I like your analysis of Johnson.

    Locke did not believe that primary qualities were in the mind. He believed that primary qualities existed in real, physical objects that existed outside of the mind.

    Berkeley's theory says that if something is not perceived, it does not exist. God is not perceived, so by Berkeley's theory, god does not exist. Berkeley tried to weasel out of this problem by claiming that god was a "notion" not an "idea." This did not impress anyone.

    ReplyDelete